Mental Health Act Section 5(2) — doctor's holding power
MHA s5(2) · Psychiatry / Behavioural
Physician-written · Verified by three sets of doctors · Reviewed November 2026
Bedside summary
Section 5(2) allows the doctor (or approved clinician) in charge of a voluntary inpatient's care — including a medical/ED inpatient already admitted to a bed — to detain them for up to 72 hours to enable a full Mental Health Act assessment when they attempt to leave and are at risk. It applies only to patients already admitted, never to those solely in the ED waiting area.
Red flags
- Organic delirium mistaken for functional disorder
- Expressed suicidal plan or means to self-harm
- Attempting to abscond with high risk to self or others
- Deterioration in GCS or new neurological signs
- Patient lacks capacity and also physically unwell
Assessment
Differential diagnosis
- Acute psychosis or mania with impaired insight wishing to self-discharge
- Severe depression with suicidal intent
- Delirium with organic cause (sepsis, hypoxia, intoxication, withdrawal)
- Capacitous refusal of treatment (not detainable under MHA for physical illness)
- Personality disorder crisis / impulsive self-discharge
Investigations
- Mental state examination and documented risk assessment
- Capacity assessment regarding the decision to leave
- Capillary glucose, observations, organic screen as indicated
- Bloods and toxicology if delirium suspected
- Collateral history from ward staff, family, crisis team
Management
- Confirm the patient is an admitted inpatient (including on a medical/ED ward) — s5(2) does not apply to patients only in the ED
- Assess and document mental disorder, risk, and that informal management is no longer appropriate
- Complete form H1 and record exact time detention begins (72-hour clock)
- Inform the patient of their rights and nursing staff; do not use s5(2) to treat
- Refer immediately for formal MHA assessment (AMHP + two doctors) — do not wait the full 72 hours
- Arrange conversion to s2/s3 or revert to informal status after assessment
- Ensure nursing staff can use s5(4) (6-hour nurse's holding power) if the doctor is unavailable
Drugs & doses
Lorazepam — 1-2 mg PO/IM for acute agitation, repeat; max 4 mg/24h caution
Haloperidol — 5 mg IM (2.5 mg elderly) with ECG, after benzodiazepine
Promethazine — 50 mg IM if benzodiazepine-tolerant
Note: s5(2) does not authorise treatment — medication requires consent or Mental Capacity Act / common-law justification
Disposition
Detain the admitted patient under s5(2) and request urgent AMHP-led MHA assessment for conversion to s2/s3 or reversion to informal status; never discharge a high-risk patient on s5(2) without psychiatric review.
Complications & pitfalls
- Unlawful detention if used for a patient not yet admitted
- Delay in formal assessment leaving patient in legal limbo
- Treating under s5(2) (not permitted) leading to challenge
- Absconding before AMHP assessment
- Breach of 72-hour limit without conversion
Exam pearls
- s5(2) buys time only — it is a holding power, not a treatment order, and cannot be renewed
- It cannot be applied in the ED majors/waiting area; the patient must be admitted to a bed first
- Nurses hold s5(4) for 6 hours pending a doctor; this time counts within the s5(2) window if converted
- Document the specific risks that make informal management unsafe
- Capacity to refuse physical treatment is governed by the Mental Capacity Act, not the MHA
Disclaimer: Educational decision support for qualified clinicians and students — not a substitute for clinical judgement, local protocols or a full drug reference. Confirm every dose and contraindication against your formulary before prescribing.