Suspected spider bite - diagnostic approach (when it is NOT a spider)
Bedside summary
Spider bites are rare and heavily over-diagnosed. There is no laboratory test for spider venom; a bite is definitive only if all three hold: a spider was seen inflicting it, the spider was recovered and identified, and a compatible lesion/systemic finding is present. In a review of 600 presumed bites, 80% were better attributed to other causes; in an ED series of 182 chief-complaints of spider bite, 84% were skin/soft-tissue infection and only 3 had an identified spider. The ED priority is to avoid anchoring on spider bite and missing CA-MRSA and other dangerous mimics.
Red flags
- Necrotic or rapidly enlarging ulcer (think CA-MRSA, pyoderma gangrenosum, ecthyma, anthrax - not reflexively Loxosceles)
- Systemic illness: fever, haemolysis, haemoglobinuria, thrombocytopenia - systemic loxoscelism can be fatal in 12-30 h, especially in children, before the lesion evolves
- Multiple or bilateral lesions (this is NOT a spider bite)
- Organophosphate-like toxidrome: salivation, fasciculations, pulmonary oedema (funnel-web)
- Priapism / autonomic storm (Phoneutria)
Assessment
Differential diagnosis
- CA-MRSA and other skin/soft-tissue infection (far more prevalent than spider bites)
- Early Lyme (erythema migrans) / STARI
- Herpes zoster or simplex (including herpetic whitlow)
- Other arthropod bites (ants, fleas, bedbugs, ticks, mites, mosquitoes, biting flies)
- Scorpion sting
- Toxicodendron (poison ivy/oak) dermatitis
- Pyoderma gangrenosum
- Neutrophilic dermatosis of the dorsal hands / Sweet syndrome
- Cutaneous vasculitis, ecthyma, anthrax, burns, diabetic/vascular ulcer
Investigations
- Clinical assessment; apply the diagnostic and exclusion criteria
- Unroof and culture papules/pustules to identify infection (especially CA-MRSA)
- No serologic or laboratory test for spider venom exists
- Biopsy when pyoderma gangrenosum / neutrophilic dermatosis suspected (plus vasculitis and coagulation work-up for PG)
- Regional poison centre (1-800-222-1222) / medical toxicology for genuine significant envenomation
Management
- Apply exclusion criteria: multiple lesions, lesions on widely separated body parts, or several affected household members essentially EXCLUDE a spider bite - pursue another diagnosis
- Take a careful history: was a spider actually seen and recovered? Is the geography/habitat consistent?
- For a solitary lesion with no witnessed spider, presume infection or another cause and evaluate/treat accordingly
- For genuine envenomation, manage per species (recluse, widow, funnel-web, Phoneutria) and involve poison centre/toxicology
- Wash the site, provide analgesia and supportive care, and update tetanus
Drugs & doses
Disposition
Complications & pitfalls
- Delayed treatment of CA-MRSA, necrotising infection, or pyoderma gangrenosum from misdiagnosis
- Unnecessary antibiotics or antivenom
- Secondary infection of genuine bites
Exam pearls
- The diagnostic triad is rarely met even in published reports
- Single lesion = possible; multiple lesions = look elsewhere
- A necrotic lesion in a region without recluse spiders is usually CA-MRSA
- Many internet images of Loxosceles bites are actually misidentified neutrophilic dermatosis
- Tarantula urticating hairs (not bites) cause skin/eye irritation and rare anaphylaxis
Disclaimer: Educational decision support for qualified clinicians and students — not a substitute for clinical judgement, local protocols or a full drug reference. Confirm every dose and contraindication against your formulary before prescribing.